One shoe off

September 12, 2007

in the poor house

Editor’s note: This was written a couple of weeks ago. It’s a little overdue, but I thought I would share it 1) in the interest of having some kind of content on this blog and 2) because the themes of “affluenza,” poverty and consumerism are ones that continually bounce up to the surface.

So, Tony Snow finally announced his resignation. Funny how people around Bush are dropping like flies. It’s like the party guests who go home early, not hanging around to be rousted off the floor or couch and thrown out by the host.

Funny, also, how Mr. Snow cites financial reasons for leaving his job. Apparently, as White House spokesperson he made a paltry $168,000, which he says isn’t enough to support his family. FYI the median income for a family of five in D.C. is $35,754. Yet, Mr. Snow claims he “had to take out a loan” in order to make ends meet when he left his high-paying Fox job to come to the White House. And yet, his income of $168k puts him in the top 5 percent. So, there are 3 options, as I see it:
1) He’s lying, and he’s really leaving because of a) his cancer or b) everyone else is leaving.

2) Tony Snow and his family, like a huge chunk of people, are mired in debt. For the average American, that’s nearly $19,000 in consumer debt, not counting mortgages. The average principal on a mortgage is about $69,000. So, let’s for fun say that the average American owes about $90,000. We’ll pretend Mr. Snow is indeed average. I suppose that, were his family to suddenly need to pay off all their debt all at once, an income $168,000 would be a little tight. (Failing to point out, however, that even that scenario would leave him with $78,000 to live off of. More than twice the median income mentioned above).

3) Mr. Snow lives way beyond his means. There is no reason at all why a five person family cannot have all their needs — food, shelter, clothing, water — met on $168k a year. Yes Mr. Snow has been ill, but federal employees are one of the few groups of people who DO have good insurance. And what about all that money he was making at Fox? Do you mean to tell me he saved NONE of it? He’s burnt through it all?

I’ve been afraid for a very long time that the industrialized world is going to run into an economic catastrophe on the scale of the Great Depression sometime in the next 50 years. My biggest fear, though, is that we’ve lost the skills to deal with that kind of catastrophe. Cable TV and (and to a lesser extent Internet access) have become “utilities” that are considered equal to electricity or gas service. We each spend about $2100 a year on restaurant meals. We’ve forgotten how to soak a bean, much less bake a loaf of bread. God forbid we brew our own coffee, or drink tap water from a glass.

Maybe my Walden Pond complex is coming back … every once in awhile I get this urge to dramatically simplify my life and start valuing NON-thing things. I can’t help but think that as a person of faith I need to take seriously Jesus’ command to live a life where people matter much more than things, and where we stop worrying about the money and live instead lives that are more humane. Lives that are more human.


  1. This is really great! I’m glad you’ve got a political streak…this’ll be fun to read.

    Comment by Tom Hoberg — September 13, 2007 @ 1:05 pm | Reply

  2. I’m completely convinced that the poverty of affluence is ruining our country. Debt, credit cards, out-of-control spending, two-income families, “needs” for new cars and restaurant meals . . .

    I miss good old fashioned frugality. Although I’m not yet forty, I long for the good old days when people lived according to their means. Today everyone assumes that a family requires two incomes because of the basic need for cable tv, a mini van and an SUV, annual Caribbean vacations and weekly trips to the mall.

    It’s tough to focus on what matters when we’re drowning in our stuff.

    Comment by Michelle Scheidt — September 14, 2007 @ 6:13 am | Reply

  3. I think people like Tony Snow may not consider themselves “average people” and thus feel they deserve to live beyond thier means. Why do something like that when you have a status to maintain and prove how special, powerful and not average you are?

    This reminds me of when congress bought gold toilet seats(or something of the like) in the 90’s.

    Comment by Aharona — September 14, 2007 @ 8:53 am | Reply

  4. it’s totally the problem of keeping up with the joneses (no offense intended…). i have no passion for a simple life, i love all my stuff with a passion, have TONS of stuff, and have to keep getting rid of stuff to aquire more stuff. but it means i have to pay close attention to my money so i don’t buy more stuff than i can afford, and while i’d love to say i save up for stuff i can’t afford and buy it when i have the money, actually the best i can say is i take care to pay off the charge cards before i binge on any more stuff.

    Comment by caitlin leah — September 16, 2007 @ 11:26 am | Reply

RSS feed for comments on this post. TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at

%d bloggers like this: